That was the case during testimony regarding the proposed Four Creeks Wind Project in Peoria County, Illinois. Strategic Economic Research President Dr. David Loomis testified about SER's analysis of the project's potential economic impacts, including construction and long-term employment, local economic activity, and property tax revenue.
Over the course of the hearing, attorneys representing both the applicant and project opponents examined not only the results of the study, but also the assumptions behind them. Here is a high-level play-by-play of some of the major economic questions that emerged—and how they were addressed.
Should Economic Impacts Even Be Considered?
Before Dr. Loomis began presenting the study, counsel opposing the project objected to the testimony itself, arguing that economic impact was not specifically identified among the applicable zoning criteria.
Four Creeks' attorney responded that economic impacts were relevant to the broader consideration of the general welfare of Peoria County.
The hearing officer ultimately overruled the objection, finding economic impact to be within the permissible scope of the proceeding and allowing the Zoning Board of Appeals to determine how much weight to give the testimony.
That ruling set the stage for a detailed discussion about what the project could mean economically for the county.
What Exactly Did the Economic Study Measure?
Four Creeks' attorney began by establishing the scope of SER's work. Dr. Loomis explained that the analysis examined four primary areas:
- Jobs supported by construction and operation of the project
- Labor earnings associated with those jobs
- Broader economic output
- Property tax revenue generated for local taxing jurisdictions
The analysis used an input-output economic model to distinguish between spending that occurs locally, spending elsewhere in Illinois, and expenditures that leave the region altogether. That distinction is important because dollars spent locally can circulate through the economy, while expenditures made outside the study area are treated as economic "leakage."
The analysis further separated impacts into three categories: direct impacts associated with the project itself, supply-chain impacts resulting from purchases of goods and services, and induced impacts created when workers and others receiving income spend money in the local economy.
That distinction would later become one of the central issues during cross-examination.
Does “688 Jobs” Mean 688 People Working on the Wind Farm?
One of the most significant exchanges involved the study's estimate of 688 Peoria County jobs associated with construction. Opposition counsel questioned whether that meant 688 construction workers would physically work at the project site.
The answer was no.
The study uses full-time-equivalent job years, rather than simply counting individual workers. A job is normalized as 40 hours per week for 52 weeks. Two people working half-time for a year, for example, would equal one full-time-equivalent job.
More importantly, the 688 figure does not refer only to workers assembling turbines. The estimate includes multiple categories of economic activity associated with project development and construction, including direct project-development and on-site labor, supply-chain activity, and induced economic activity.
Earlier in the testimony, Dr. Loomis had explained that the analysis estimated 233 direct project-development and on-site labor jobs, with additional employment supported through the supply chain and broader local economy.
Under cross-examination, the distinction became important: an economic impact model measures employment supported throughout the economy, not simply the number of hard hats visible on a construction site.
Are All of Those Workers Actually From Peoria County?
Another line of questioning focused on geography. If a construction worker belongs to a local union but lives outside Peoria County, does his or her activity still count as a local economic benefit?
Opposition counsel pointed out that a local union can include workers living across multiple counties and questioned whether that uncertainty could affect the estimates.
Dr. Loomis explained that SER attempts to account for exactly that issue. The model does not simply assume that every worker involved with the project lives in Peoria County. Based on experience with Illinois projects and regional economic data, the analysis estimates what portion of labor and spending is likely to occur inside the county versus elsewhere.
But he also acknowledged the inherent limitation: it is an estimate. Until a project is built and every worker is hired, no economic model can identify exactly where every future employee will live.
That exchange illustrated an important part of economic impact analysis: defining the geographic study area and accounting for spending that leaves it.
How Can Eight On-Site Employees Support Nearly 100 Long-Term Jobs?
The same issue resurfaced during discussion of the project's operational impacts. Opposition counsel focused on the relatively small number of people expected to directly maintain the turbines and contrasted that number with the study's estimate of approximately 97 ongoing jobs supported in Peoria County.
How do a handful of wind-farm employees turn into almost 100 jobs?
Dr. Loomis clarified that the additional jobs were not simply a multiplier applied to the eight maintenance workers.
The operational impact also includes ongoing expenditures associated with running the wind farm. Those can include purchases of local goods and services, economic activity supported by property-tax revenues, and other expenditures flowing through businesses and households.
In other words, the model asks a broader question than, “How many people does the wind farm directly employ?” It asks, “How much employment throughout the local economy is supported by the project's ongoing economic activity?”
That difference between direct employment and total employment supported became one of the most important concepts explained during the hearing.
What if Wind Turbine Components Are Manufactured Somewhere Else?
Opposition counsel also questioned where the turbines and their components would be manufactured. That matters because purchasing a turbine manufactured outside Illinois does not create the same local economic impact as buying concrete or labor locally.
Dr. Loomis explained that the model already accounts for this distinction. For purposes of the Peoria County and Illinois analyses, equipment manufactured outside Illinois is treated as spending leaving the study region. Whether a component comes from Iowa, Colorado, Europe, or Asia does not create additional Illinois manufacturing impacts in the model.
This is the concept economists refer to as leakage.
It prevents the analysis from assigning a local multiplier to dollars that are actually spent somewhere else. The exchange highlighted why accurately identifying the location of project expenditures is critical to economic impact modeling.
Are the Tax Estimates Too High?
Property tax revenue received substantial scrutiny as well. Illinois provides a statutory methodology for valuing wind projects for property-tax purposes. SER's analysis applied that methodology and estimated the revenue that could flow to Peoria County, school districts, townships, fire districts, libraries, and other local taxing bodies.
Four Creeks' attorney walked through several important assumptions with Dr. Loomis. Among them were the statutory depreciation schedule, an assumed inflation/trending factor, and the assumption that local tax rates would remain at their current levels rather than increasing over the project's life.
Holding tax rates constant for decades creates a more conservative projection.
The analysis estimated approximately $11.5 million in local property taxes during the first year, with revenues initially declining as statutory depreciation occurs. Once the project reaches the statutory depreciation floor, inflation indexing causes taxable value—and therefore estimated tax revenue—to begin increasing again.
Who Receives the Property Tax Revenue?
Four Creeks' attorney then moved from the methodology to a more practical question: where does the money go? The analysis estimated that local taxing districts could receive approximately $307 million over the project's 40-year life. Of that amount:
- Approximately $30.6 million was estimated for Peoria County.
- Approximately $193 million was estimated for local school districts.
- Roughly 62% of the total local property-tax revenue was expected to flow to schools.
The remaining revenue would be distributed among other taxing jurisdictions within the project footprint, with amounts varying depending on turbine locations and individual taxing rates.
Four Creeks' attorney also emphasized that the tax projections were based on assumptions intended to avoid overstating the results—including essentially assuming no increase in local tax rates over the 40-year projection period.
What Doesn't an Economic Impact Study Measure?
Another important exchange concerned the boundaries of the analysis. Opposition counsel raised potential costs associated with wind development, including issues involving farming operations, construction disruption, soil compaction, drainage tile damage, and access.
Dr. Loomis explained that some of those items can enter the economic analysis when they appear as project costs or compensation paid to landowners. Other claimed effects are not necessarily costs that an economic impact model such as this one is designed to quantify.
That distinction matters.
An economic impact analysis is not intended to answer every question raised during a permitting proceeding. It examines specific economic flows—project spending, employment, labor income, tax revenue, and lease payments.
